This book discusses "relational aggression" - female family bullying - from all angles: mother/daughter, sister/sister, mother-in-law/daughter-in-law, sisters-in-law, etc. The big issues are intimidation, belittling, the silent treatment, jealousy, rivalry, exclusion, and betrayal. Dr. Cheryl Dellasega has included first-hand stories alongside her observations, making it really juicy! Let's dive in to see how I'm affected.
Mothers-in-Law
Chapter 12 is entitled "Mothers and Sisters, By Law" and it mentions quite a bit that isn't relevant to my relationship with my MIL, thankfully. One of the first "mother-in-law missteps" with regard to the treatment of a daughter-in-law has actually happened between us, and recently, too. I literally laughed out loud when I read it!
"Tracy's mother-in-law bought Christmas gifts that only her son would obviously enjoy, but addressed them to the couple."My husband and I received a joint Christmas gift this past year - a carpet cleaner
I have to say that my MIL and I did not start off on the wrong foot or have a bad beginning, like some of the stories recounted in this book. In my opinion, we got along as well as can be expected. After all, I was her son's first girlfriend ... and yes, his only one, as it turned out. That, I think, was a stressor for her, and I understand why. I can imagine that I will want my son to become familiar with more than one girl before he decides to marry her. I definitely appreciate it, sure, but being on the girlfriend side of the relationship, it really hurts when your boyfriend's mom suggests that he play the field. (This will be a great entry to look back on when my children are grown.)
A good point to keep in mind (and a reason to not push your husband to choose between you and his mother [which I never did, by the way]):
"Reflecting back, she recognizes the real reason for the conflict: both she and her mother-in-law were struggling to establish themselves as the main woman in her husband's life."Struggles between us are not just between us (I don't think). Holiday planning, frequency of visits, and which set of parents we spend more time with are the hot-button issues, and they obviously include my husband. The fact of the matter is that we rather enjoy being just "us" - the two of us and our two children. We want to have our own experiences, and enjoy each other on the weekends since we both work full-time and don't have any quality time throughout the week. What can I say? My husband and I are selfish.
Sisters-in-Law
I thank God for the wonderful sisters-in-law that I am blessed to be "wed" to. It is disheartening to see all of the horrible SIL stories in this book! I've heard of straight-outta-Hades MILs before, but the mean SILs in this book are new to me. Fighting over who has the better kids (okay, maybe this isn't so foreign when I think of the rest of my family, but it's not an issue my SILs and I have), trying to be closer to the brother than the wife is, trying to out-do each other with birthday parties (of all things!), etc. Steph and Michelle, I love you both!
Some of My Favorite Tips for Keeping My Sanity (and some I should totally put to use):
- "Recognize that you can't change or control anyone but yourself."
- "Listen before leaping in to respond. Keep your expression and body language neutral ..."
- "Have a time limit when you're with a woman who upsets you."
- "Take a sabbatical from her. Accept that sometimes you may have to limit contact or even walk away from a relationship."
- "Plan to forgive, wipe the slate clean, and agree to start over. It may be undeserved, but treat other women as you would like to be treated, even if they can't or won't reciprocate. You will benefit, even if others don't."
- "Create a lot of moments to enjoy by recognizing your mother-in-law or daughter-in-law for who she is, separate from your husband or son."
Something I had really hoped to see addressed in this book that wasn't, is the struggle between parents and grandparents. My beef with this is that it is frequently obvious that my MIL puts her grandchildren head and shoulders above her son (and certainly me). Her visits are primarily to see them, and often, we can sit in a room and not even have a conversation so long as she's interacting with them. He doesn't speak of it much, but I can tell that it bothers my husband. Grandparents, please remember that without your child and his/her spouse, there would be no grandchildren. We'd love to have your affection, too.
My Mother
Again, I am so blessed. Unlike the stories in the book, I've never once sensed that there was jealousy between my mother and I, or any kind of real animosity. We don't sabotage or backstab each other. She doesn't offer unsolicited advice, and when she's asked for advice, she replies tactfully. She adores my husband as much as my children; we all have a place in her heart. In fact, both she and my grandmother agree that if James and I were to ever be divorced, he would not be able to divorce my family! That's real in-law love, y'all!
So do I recommend this book? Yes, but unless you just can't manage to get along with any woman anywhere, you won't need to read the whole thing. Skip around to the relationships relevant to you and you will definitely find a few treasures.
